In September 2012, Ilana Yurkiewicz reported on a Yale study that analyzed gender bias in the science fields. In the study, scientists reviewed identical resumes for the job of lab manager assistant, half with a man’s name attached and half with a woman’s name attached. According to Yurkiewicz, “Results found that the ‘female’ applicants were rated significantly lower than the ‘males’ in competence, hireability, and whether the scientist would be willing to mentor the student” (Yurkiewicz, 2012).
The surprising outcome to many was that the women and the men showed the same bias. Indeed, it seems quite unlikely that if questioned after, the scientists would say that female scientists were less capable and yet, the perception in this study was that female scientists are less competent and less hireable. The results did not come from overt sexism, but rather from hidden or implicit bias.
Sometimes we do not tell the truth, and sometimes we don’t know the truth. Sometimes it’s intentional and sometimes it’s unconscious. When it is an unconscious bias for or against someone or something, it is referred to as an implicit bias. Implicit biases are social stereotypes that we form outside of our own consciousness. They:
- Stem from our brain’s adaptations to information and experiences from our past.
- Create unconscious barriers in the classroom.
- Impact how we relate to people, make decisions, and communicate.
Our implicit biases are conveyed through our micromessages. Certainly, our students’ self-efficacy and willingness to persevere in a nontraditional or STEM program is greatly impacted by the reception she or he perceives she or he receives in a classroom. We all hold biases (intentionally or unintentionally) within us based upon our history, our cultural interactions, and our family of origins. (We will look at self-efficacy in more detail in Section 4.)
The figure below shows the mutually reinforcing factors that are at play in the transmission and reception of micromessages.
Figure 3: National Alliance for Partnerships in Equity (NAPE) Culture Wheel
It is only through awareness that we can change our biases, or at least mitigate the impact they may have on students. One way of becoming aware of your own implicit biases is to take part in Harvard University’s Implicit Association Tests (IAT). The IAT tests can be found on the Project Implicit website at www.implicit.harvard.edu. The IAT measures the strength of associations between topics (e.g. gender and science, weight) and judgments (e.g. good or bad) or stereotypes (e.g. bossy, incompetent). The main idea is the closer the association, the faster the response. These are quick and easy tests that can really help you become aware of your own unintended biases.
A link to the Project Implicit page will be included in the list of resources sent to you upon completion of the module.